[JenBurdoo] Whistle While You Work

[JenBurdoo]

Vic works for Kyle. For irrelevant reasons, Kyle decides to murder Vic. One day while Vic is on the job, Kyle whistles - and Vic dies. Explain.

[Earnest]

Vic and Kyle = HAM?

So not relevant why he decided to murder Vic right?

whistles = a signal for someone else? Did Kyle kill Vic? If so with: knife? gun? by manipulating some tool/mechanism/engine? Electroshock? Drowning? poison? gas? strangulation? Did Kyle whistle to cover a noise? To witness that he was not taking part to the murder of Vic when it happened? Because he wanted to reproduce a noise? Was he whistling a song? Or maybe doing a "plain" whistle without any particular melody? Did Kyle relevantly worked in the control tower and Vic was a pilot? Communications relevant?
Did Vic heard Kyle whistling when dying?
Did Kyle whistles soon before Vic's death? Seconds before? Minutes? Hours? Days?

Was Vic the only one dying? Did Vic die directly because of Kyle whistling? Indirectly because of it?

Is Kyle and Vic job the same? If so relevant which one? A job at risk? Scientists?

[JenBurdoo]

Vic and Kyle = HAM? Yes to both.

So not relevant why he decided to murder Vic right? No.

whistles = a signal for someone else? Yes. Did Kyle kill Vic? Not in person. If so with: knife? gun? by manipulating some tool/mechanism/engine? For a sufficiently vague value. Electroshock? Drowning? poison? gas? strangulation? None of the others. Did Kyle whistle to cover a noise? No. To witness that he was not taking part to the murder of Vic when it happened? No. Because he wanted to reproduce a noise? No. Was he whistling a song? No. Or maybe doing a "plain" whistle without any particular melody? This. Did Kyle relevantly worked in the control tower and Vic was a pilot? No. Communications relevant? In the sense of a signal, yes.
Did Vic heard Kyle whistling when dying? No.
Did Kyle whistles soon before Vic's death? Seconds before? This. Minutes? Hours? Days?

Was Vic the only one dying? Yes. Did Vic die directly because of Kyle whistling? Indirectly because of it? This, but an argument can perhaps be made for directly.

[irishelk]

Was the whistle a signal for one other person? For a group? For an animal? Was the someone being signaled to aware of the murder plot? Were they physically near Vic? If so, were they aware of him?

Would the whistle usually indicate some kind of "all clear"? Was it an instruction to start machinery?

[Balin]

Was the whistle audible to the human ear? To Vic? To Kyle?

[JenBurdoo]

Was the whistle a signal for one other person? For a group? For an animal? This. Was the someone being signaled to aware of the murder plot? No. Were they physically near Vic? Yes. If so, were they aware of him? Irr.

Would the whistle usually indicate some kind of "all clear"? Was it an instruction to start machinery? No to both.

Was the whistle audible to the human ear? No. To Vic? To Kyle?

[wolfier]

Is the setting a marine park? If so, is an orca involved?
Does Kyle know that Vic works for him?

[GalFisk]

Did the animal, when it heard the whistle: move? Kill? Attack? Buck? Kick? Bite? Peck? Leave? Also die? Was the animal trained to respond to the whistle? If so, was it trained specifically for the murder? Is it a mammal? Bird? Reptile? Insect? Arachnid? Amphibian? Fish?

[Earnest]

Circus relevant? Was one of the two a tiger breeder?

[JenBurdoo]

Is the setting a marine park? If so, is an orca involved? No to both.

Does the animal, when it heard the whistle: move? This. Kill? Attack? Buck? Kick? Bite? Peck? Leave? And this. Also die? None of the rest. Was the animal trained to respond to the whistle? Yes. If so, was it trained specifically for the murder? Irr. Is it a mammal? This. Bird? Reptile? Insect? Arachnid? Amphibian? Fish?

Does Kyle know that Vic works for him? Yes.

Circus relevant? Was one of the two a tiger breeder? No to both.

[WiZ]

Is the animal a dog? Is it a police dog? Vic's service dog, which leaves Vic vulnerable in its absence?

[JenBurdoo]

Is the animal a dog? Yes. Is it a police dog? Vic's service dog, which leaves Vic vulnerable in its absence? No to both, though I like the second one.

[GalFisk]

Did the dog, when leaving, cause a problem? Cause the death? Did the dog have a relevant job? Such as guarding? Sniffing? Searching?

[JenBurdoo]

Did the dog, when leaving, cause a problem? Cause the death? This. Did the dog have a relevant job? No. Such as guarding? Sniffing? Searching?

[Balin]

Is the dog a guide dog? Is Vic blind?

[JenBurdoo]

Is the dog a guide dog? Is Vic blind? No to both.

[GalFisk]

Death by: suffocation? Strangulation? Hanging? Drowning? Exposure? Thirst? Hunger? Cold? Heat? Fire? Explosion? Firearm? Weapon? Human action (apart from calling the dog away)? Shock? Fear? Blood loss? Organ damage? Disease? Infection? Impact? Fall? Crushing? Vehicle? Poison? Venom? Animal action (apart from the dog leaving)? Suicide? Overdose? Malfunction of a device?

[JenBurdoo]

Death by: suffocation? Strangulation? Hanging? Drowning? Exposure? Thirst? Hunger? Cold? Heat? Fire? Explosion? Firearm? Weapon? Human action (apart from calling the dog away)? Shock? Fear? Blood loss? Organ damage? Disease? Infection? Impact? Fall? This. Crushing? Vehicle? Poison? Venom? Animal action (apart from the dog leaving)? Explore. Suicide? Overdose? Malfunction of a device?

[GalFisk]

Is the dog leashed? To something? Is the fall a result of: tripping? Being pushed? Being startled? A collapse? Is it a fall from a height? Down stairs? Down a well? Does the dog leaving cause the fall? Make it certain to happen? Likely to happen? Does the victim: see the dog? Hear it? Hold it? Follow it? Chase it?Try to prevent it from leaving? From going somewhere?

[JenBurdoo]

Is the dog leashed? No. To something? Is the fall a result of: tripping? Being pushed? YMMV. Being startled? A collapse? Is it a fall from a height? This. Down stairs? Down a well? Does the dog leaving cause the fall? Yes. Make it certain to happen? Assume this. Likely to happen? Does the victim: see the dog? Hear it? Likely, but not necessarily. Hold it? Follow it? Chase it?Try to prevent it from leaving? From going somewhere? None of the others.

[biograd]

Was the dog preventing him from falling by being where it was before leaving? or does the dog pass somewhere along its path that causes the fall?

Could only a dog serve whatever purpose the dog was serving in this workplace? or could a person too, in some cases?(aside from the fact, of course, that a person is unlikely to be signaled to by whistling rather than being told verbally to do things, and that a person may understand the consequences and choose to disobey)

[JenBurdoo]

Was the dog preventing him from falling by being where it was before leaving? or does the dog pass somewhere along its path that causes the fall? This.

Could only a dog serve whatever purpose the dog was serving in this workplace? or could a person too, in some cases?(aside from the fact, of course, that a person is unlikely to be signaled to by whistling rather than being told verbally to do things, and that a person may understand the consequences and choose to disobey) It would be possible for a human to have done as the dog did, yes.

[GalFisk]

Does the dog run past the victim? Is there relevantly a dangerous area on the job? Is it a construction site? Industrial facility? Safety equipment relevant? Such as ropes? Railings? Harnesses? Does anything besides the victim fall? Such as a lift? Is the weight of the dog relevant? Size?

[JenBurdoo]

Does the dog run past the victim? Yes. Is there relevantly a dangerous area on the job? Yes. Is it a construction site? Assume this if you wish. Industrial facility? Safety equipment relevant? Such as ropes? Railings? Harnesses? None are present. Does anything besides the victim fall? Yes. Such as a lift? No. Is the weight of the dog relevant? Size? To the extent that it's large enough for Kyle's purpose.

[GalFisk]

Does the dog fall? An object? Multiple objects? A substance? Another human? Does the victim relevantly respond to the dog? Does the victim grab, step or lean on something that is too weak to support him?

[JenBurdoo]

Does the dog fall? No. An object? This. Multiple objects? A substance? Another human? No to the rest. Does the victim relevantly respond to the dog? No. Does the victim grab, step or lean on something that is too weak to support him? No.

[wolfier]

Would the victim still fall if none of those other fallen objects were present?
Did these objects fall before the victim did, or after?

[JenBurdoo]

Would the victim still fall if none of those other fallen objects were present? No.
Did these objects fall before the victim did, or after? Neither.

[GalFisk]

Does the object fall on Vic? From under Vic? Does Vic die from trying to get aawy from the falling object? From being hit by it? Is the object bigger than Vic? Heavier?

[JenBurdoo]

Does the object fall on Vic? From under Vic? This. Does Vic die from trying to get away from the falling object? No. From being hit by it? No. Is the object bigger than Vic? Yes. Heavier? No.

[Mimino]

Was it Vic's dog? Kyle's?
Did Vic stand on the object that fell? was it a scaffold? a ladder? a plank?
Was the dog a counterweight of some sort? which made something tip over when he left the place?

[JenBurdoo]

Was it Vic's dog? Kyle's? This.
Did Vic stand on the object that fell? Yes. was it a scaffold? a ladder? Assume this. a plank?
Was the dog a counterweight of some sort? No. which made something tip over when he left the place? But yes.

Quite close to solution.